Reading special education data from the bottom up

Written by

in

About 4 minutes to read

Every year, school districts send the federal government a long list of numbers about students with disabilities: how many have IEPs, where they spend the school day, how they left school, how often they were suspended. The numbers are public, and IDEA Atlas puts them in one place for every district in the country.

Reading from the bottom up matters to me. I have a visual impairment. I grew up in India, and I now study U.S. schools. I live the idea of bottom up every day. I also see it in families. Parents come looking for support for their child, and they are handed a mandate they have to learn to read first. These numbers are part of that mandate, and I want them to be something families can actually use.

This post starts a short series on how to read them from the bottom up. Each post takes one of the atlas guides and asks what the numbers can tell you, what they cannot, and how a family member, teacher or school leader might use them.

Two ways to read a number

Policy researchers describe two ways to study how a law works. One starts at the top, with what the law says, and follows it down to the classroom, checking whether each level did its part. Richard Elmore (1979) called this forward mapping. The other starts at the bottom, with the moment a service reaches a student, and works back up to ask what made that moment go well or badly. He called this backward mapping.

Federal special education data is built for forward mapping. Each figure answers a compliance question: did the district report it, and did it meet the target? That is useful. But families and teachers usually start from the other end, with one child, one classroom, one meeting.

Reading from the bottom up means treating a district figure as the trace of thousands of small decisions, not as a verdict. Michael Lipsky (1980) showed that teachers and other front-line workers make policy through the choices they make every day, under real limits of time, caseload and resources. A placement percentage is the sum of those choices.

What the school system does to the numbers

Thomas Skrtic has long argued that special education is shaped by how schools are organized, not only by what students need (Skrtic, 1991). When an outside mandate arrives, schools often answer it with “symbols and ceremonies of change” that leave classroom practice as it was (Skrtic, 2005).

For reading data, this means a figure can change because the paperwork changed. A district can report students differently without changing where or how they learn. Before reading a jump as progress or decline, ask what changed in the system that produced it.

Elizabeth Kozleski’s work adds another layer. In a study of school system change, Kozleski and Smith (2009) found that reform moved through the stories a school community told about its children as much as through new structures. The same number can carry very different stories depending on who tells it.

What the numbers leave out

Disability studies in education starts from a simple point: disability is understood through the settings, expectations and judgments around a person, not only through a diagnosis (Connor et al., 2008). Federal data cannot see any of that. It counts students in categories that adults assigned. It records time spent in a general classroom, not whether a student was taught well there. It has no measure of whether a student feels they belong.

That is not a reason to set the numbers aside. It is a reason to hold them loosely, and to bring the people they describe into the conversation.

Four habits for reading from the bottom up

  • Check who is counted. “Per 100” can mean per 100 students or per 100 students with IEPs.
  • Compare with your own state. Rules and funding differ a great deal between states, so the typical district in your state is the fairest comparison.
  • Look at the counts behind the rate. In a small district, a few students can move a figure a long way.
  • Write down one question. Then ask it of someone who works with students every day.

The full guide, How to read your district’s special education data, walks through each of these with examples from the atlas.

In this series

The series continues with where students with IEPs learn, discipline, who gets identified for special education, the IEP meeting, and dispute resolution. Each draws on scholars who shaped how I think about these questions, including Thomas Skrtic, Elizabeth Kozleski, Alfredo Artiles and colleagues in disability studies in education.

Sources

  • Connor, D. J., Gabel, S. L., Gallagher, D. J., & Morton, M. (2008). Disability studies and inclusive education: Implications for theory, research, and practice. International Journal of Inclusive Education, 12(5–6), 441–457. https://doi.org/10.1080/13603110802377482
  • Elmore, R. F. (1979). Backward mapping: Implementation research and policy decisions. Political Science Quarterly, 94(4), 601–616. https://doi.org/10.2307/2149628
  • Kozleski, E. B., & Smith, A. (2009). The complexities of systems change in creating equity for students with disabilities in urban schools. Urban Education, 44(4), 427–451. https://doi.org/10.1177/0042085909337595
  • Lipsky, M. (1980). Street-level bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the individual in public services. Russell Sage Foundation.
  • Skrtic, T. M. (1991). Behind special education: A critical analysis of professional culture and school organization. Love Publishing.
  • Skrtic, T. M. (2005). A political economy of learning disabilities. Learning Disability Quarterly, 28(2), 149–155.

Comments

3 responses to “Reading special education data from the bottom up”

  1. […] post continues the series that began with Reading special education data from the bottom up. After reading discipline data from the bottom up, it takes up who gets identified for special […]

  2. […] post continues the series that began with Reading special education data from the bottom up. After the iep meeting from the bottom up, it takes up complaints, mediation and due process, and […]